“Why can’t a guy and a girl just be friends?” I ask trying my hardest to impress her. I struggle to keep my eyes on the eight ball but she stands across from me, agreeing, and I look at her bright dimpled smile instead. I scratch.
Ana walks me out of the pool room, her arm tucked playfully in mine. “I’m gonna go check out the Southeast Asian Society. You should come,” she says, tugging my arm and gesturing with the tip of her head. It’s yet another of her multitude of random, unfocused interests. Thankfully, for the time being, she seems uncharacteristically focused on me. I leave her but she stays on my mind.
Ana is an army brat without an army. Her parents were National Geographic photographers, nomads following the shoot. Because she moved around so much, she developed the magical ability to charm and connect with people moments after meeting them. Later she tells me that the best thing about Yale is that she can finally stay in one place for four whole years.
I use food as an excuse to visit her. My parents send me sweets in bulk as though New Haven were shrouded in some candy embargo or great famine. I bring the food to her room, share with her roommates, and make small talk. It’s all an excuse to see Ana.
We sit outside her window sill, our legs dangling over our fellow freshmen. We drink tea and chat about how beautiful rain can be. More than once, she accidentally calls me “Sam,” the name of her long distance boyfriend.
We study in her room and battle ourselves to work and not talk. After hours of Eigen values and partial derivatives, I start to feel sleepy so I collect my things to take a nap. She stops me and invites me to sleep in her bed. As I curl up she slithers beside me, against the wall, her textbook still in hand. My heart races and I can’t sleep.
We spend too much time together. Our schoolwork suffers and our social lives slack. Then, for two days, she suddenly disappears. On both days, I share gummies with her roommates, but they don’t know where she is. For forty-eight hours, I’m lost. When I finally see her again I ask where she was, trying to sound casual. She replies vaguely, “Oh I went on this Southeast Asian Society retreat thing.” “You didn’t tell me. I was kind of worried,” I say, still trying to be casual. She simply shrugs.
When I see Ana again, she cheerfully tells me that Sam, her boyfriend, is coming to visit for a couple of days. I wonder how he can afford to skip school so early in his freshman year. Then I look at her and I understand.
Sam arrives and she introduces him to everyone, but there’s no way he can remember all of our names. I grip his hand as firmly as I can without trying to seem macho. He holds on and says, “Ana has told me all about you.” From the way he says it, I believe him. As we eat, I try to make general conversation but our lives are all so intertwined that no conversation is general. Sam observes from the periphery, barely saying anything.
The next day, Ana asks me to entertain her boyfriend for a couple of hours. She wants to try writing for the school paper or some other random thing she’s always doing. I spend the day with him, accommodating him as I would an estranged cousin. But he and I both know what our hanging out really means. He’s travelled all the way from Michigan to see her and instead he gets me. It feels like we're trying to have fun at a funeral. Around dinner time, Ana finally returns and again he’s lost in our conversation. He doesn’t even end up sitting by her.
A couple of days later, Ana knocks on my door, crying. Through her sobs, she tells me she’s just broken up with Sam. I hold her, telling her that sometimes these things are for the best. I feel guilty because I’m suppressing a smile.
Later that week, I wake up to loud talking and someone shouting, “Shhh, some of my suitemates are asleep!” I try to pat down my angry hair as I shuffle into the common room where I find Ana and some of my roommates. They're all Ted-Kennedy-drunk. One of my roommates carries Ana to his bed and we find him collapsed on her, his tongue deep down her throat. “Whoa whoa whoa!” I shout. Suddenly, I’m that guy friend, the one who acts out of brotherly protectiveness, but really it's nothing more than a thin guise for jealousy. An ex-high school football player carries her to her room and I follow like a lame sheep. I spend the rest of the night holding back her hair as she vomits. On an old dirty tiled bathroom stall, she cries and holds me for the last time.
A few days later, I find her sitting on some guy’s lap in the RA’s room, a room I would later occupy as a senior. They’ve both been eating blue lollipops and she’s running her fingers over his teeth. My dentist does this to me all the time, but like an ob-gyn exam versus being fingered, some things are more sexual when your crush is doing it. My face turns red. The RA looks at me and asks, “Aren’t you two dating?” And I shrug, honestly unsure. After blue tooth guy leaves, I find Ana and rant my head off. I don’t have the courage to tell her how I feel, but I do have the rage to insist that she’s leading blue tooth guy on. She listens quietly and doesn’t say a word. I spend the night angrily kicking pebbles across the courtyard.
For the next year, I only see her occasionally at parties and in large groups. I’m disappointed if she’s not around but don’t get to talk to her much when she is. One rainy afternoon, she taps on my window and crawls through it, leaving muddy footprints on my desk. At first, I smile then moments later I feel like I’m going to vomit. I hope she will never knock on my window again.
Two years later, due to some cosmic round of Russian roulette, I end up in Seattle and she’s there too, living with her new boyfriend, Kelvin. Out of some pig-headed politeness, I agree to hang out with her and when her boyfriend is out of town, she invites me to stay over. We chat like old lovers, but sleep on separate halves of the futon. When her boyfriend calls the next morning she gleefully says, “Guess who spent the night? Alex!” On my way out, I check to see if my teeth have turned blue.
By senior dead week, I’m barely speaking to her. I don’t force myself into her schedule like I used to and as always, she simply distracts herself with whatever new comes her way.
For dead week, we end up in Georgia with a large group of friends. Complaints filter down to me about Ana and some bad trip to Puerto Rico. Everyone is annoyed with her.
They claim she’s become a whiny know it all, challenging people’s opinions and offering her own in the most baseless fashion. I desperately want her to be flawed. I want to hate her. I hope her faults will rise to the surface like rotting, maggot infested sour grapes. But I can’t muster any anger or loathing. I simply don’t care.
Right before returning to school for graduation, we end up on the beach together. She asks me to put sunscreen on her back. Her half-Asian skin is tanned like a Brazilian model’s. My heart skips a beat. But the woman I loved is gone. Sitting before me with her hair gathered in her hands is a glossy Playboy centerfold and I am just some underage boy flipping through an old magazine.
I brush a grain of sand from her back. It falls to the beach amongst the other millions of grains of sand.